consent.jpg

Manufacturing Consent

Prince Si of Way wanted to impose mandatory vaccination, but people weren't happy about it. He complained to Boyi. People are so stupid, he said. This vaccine is for their own damned good. If they won't do it for themselves, I'll do it for them. What's the difference, anyhow?

Boyi told the prince, Just stop. If it's every man for himself and you don't organize it, that's no better than forcing it on them. If you force it on them and people have no choice, that's no better than every man for himself. Remember, governance is all about consent. Be clear so people know what's expected, be consistent because this will take a long time, and be reasonable so it's impossible to argue. Today, Yu, Xia, Yin and Zhao no longer exist. They all ignored consent.

Notes

is a grain levy, not vaccination, and is more like grain stored by (peasants) or (their lords). Otherwise I think my interpretation is more or less literal.

The key phrase, , is self-reliance in Knoblock and Riegel (The Annals of Lü Buwei), but I don't like their somewhat libertarian take on Boyi's response, though the phrase is close enough to , a Confucian idiom, for me to like personal responsibilty almost as much as I like consent.

Knoblock and Riegel emend to , which makes a lot more sense in context, but I like the triplet of phrases as advice on how to achieve consent, so I've kept .

Vocabulary

wèi
行 144 + 9
guard, protect, defend
口 30 + 10
to connect, inherit; descendants, heirs
jūn
口 30 + 4
sovereign, monarch, ruler, chief, prince
欠 76 + 7
desire, want, long for; intend
zhòng
里 166 + 2
heavy, weighty; double
shuì
禾 115 + 7
taxes, revenue, duty; tax
人 9 + 3
by means of; thereby, therefore; consider as; in order to
耳 128 + 8
assemble, meet together, collect
米 119 + 6
unhusked millet; grain
mín
氏 83 + 1
people, subjects, citizens
弓 57 + 2
not, negative
ān
宀 40 + 3
peaceful, tranquil, quiet
gào
口 30 + 4
tell, announce, inform; accuse
báo bó
艸 140 + 13
thin, slight, weak; poor, stingy
疋 103 + 9
doubt, question, suspect
yuē
曰 73 + 0
say; KangXi radical 73
shén
甘 99 + 4
great extent; considerably
心 61 + 9
stupid, doltish, foolish
矢 111 + 2
particle of completed action
大 37 + 1
man, male adult, husband; those
乙 5 + 2
also; classical final particle of strong affirmation or identity
jiāng
寸 41 + 8
will, going to, future; general
wèi
火 86 + 5
do, handle, govern, act; be
八 12 + 6
his, her, its, their; that
自 132 + 0
self, private, personal; from
cáng
艸 140 + 14
hide, conceal; hoard, store up
zhī
丿 4 + 3
marks preceding phrase as modifier of following phrase; it, him her, them; go to
臼 134 + 8
and; with; to; for; give, grant
zài
土 32 + 3
be at, in, on; consist in, rest
方 70 + 4
in, at, on; interjection alas!
shàng
一 1 + 2
top; superior, highest; go up, send up
大 37 + 7
where? what? how? why?; servant
手 64 + 13
select, choose, pick out
一 1 + 3
no, not; un-; negative prefix
rán
火 86 + 8
yes, certainly; pledge, promise
ér
而 126 + 0
and; and then; and yet; but
zhī
矢 111 + 3
know, perceive, comprehend
女 38 + 3
if, supposing; as if; like, as
fán
几 16 + 1
all, any, every; ordinary, common
tīng
耳 128 + 16
hear, listen; understand; obey
心 61 + 1
surely, most certainly; must
fǎn
又 29 + 2
reverse, opposite, contrary, anti
zhū
言 149 + 9
several, various
己 49 + 0
self, oneself; personal, private; 6th heavenly stem
shěn
宀 40 + 12
examine, investigate; judge
刀 18 + 7
rule, law, regulation; grades
lìng
人 9 + 3
command, order; 'commandant', magistrate; allow, cause
火 86 + 8
negative, no, not; lack, have no
guó
囗 31 + 8
nation, country, nation-state
jiǔ
丿 4 + 2
long time (ago); time passage, grow late
囗 31 + 5
to become solid, solidify; strength
nán
隹 172 + 11
difficult, arduous, hard; unable
wáng
亠 8 + 1
death, destroyed; lose, perish
jīn
人 9 + 2
now, today, modern era
虍 141 + 7
concerned about, anxious, worried
xià
夊 35 + 7
summer; great, grand, big
yīn
殳 79 + 6
many, great; abundant, flourishing
zhōu
口 30 + 5
Zhou dynasty; circumference
cún
子 39 + 3
exist, live, be; survive; remain
zhě
老 125 + 4
that which; he who; those who
jiē
白 106 + 4
all, every, everybody
qiú
水 85 + 2
seek; demand, request; beseech